(共44张PPT)
There are so many sources of information nowadays. Do you believe everything spreading online Why or Why not
Sometimes I do, but it depends. If the news is reported by a news agency that is trustworthy, then I will usually believe the report. However, if the news is from a source that I am not familiar with, I will often check other sources to compare the information in the reports. Moreover, if a headline seems to be too exaggerated to be true, then I will also check other news reports to confirm whether it is a true story.
[ ɡ z d re t d]
Pre-reading
What is the focus of each news report based on the headlines
News One
News Two
Firefighters put out tower block fire
Deadly fire in tower block causes serious damage
高层建筑;办公大楼
fire
emergency services
started
8th floor
15th floor
called
reached the scene
spread/ trapped/
got ...under control
11pm
15min, 9:45
extended
The number of deaths could reach 9,
4 confirmed death
the number of injuries dozens of , 5 in a critical condition
could reach 5
not mentioned
Can you see why they contain different information
fire
emergency services
started
8th floor
15th floor
called, 9:30
reached the scene
9:45
spread/ trapped/ extended
got ...under control
11pm
a dropped cigarette end on a carpet
the automatic fire alarms did not go off quickly enough .
a team+ is investigating...
there was concern...the construction company... had not followed the fire safety rules
by the morning
4+dozens of..+5
10 July
11 July
The structure of a news report
倒金字塔结构
The lead
Detailed information about the event
Background or supporting information
News 2
Deadly fire in tower block causes serious damage
Sentence:
Sentence:
Sentence:
Sentence:
Sentence:
Sentence:
News 1
Firefighters put out tower block fire
The lead
Detailed information about the event
Background or supporting information
News 2
Deadly fire in tower block causes serious damage
Sentence:
Sentence:
Sentence:
Sentence:
Sentence:
Sentence:
News 1
Firefighters put out tower block fire
1
2-6
7
1
2-4
5-10
Expressions characterizing the news report
1. The fire, which is thought to have started from the 8th floor, spread quickly through the tower block on Sunday night, leaving people on the upper floors trapped.
People think that the fire started from the 8th floor and spread quickly through the tower block on Sunday night, leaving people on the upper floors trapped.
Do: 用客观事物作主语,显得客观,可信度更高。
Don’t : 避免用不确切的人物作主语,显得不可信
Expressions characterizing the news report
2. Fears grew that the number of deaths could reach 5, according to figures released by emergency services.
People feared that the number of deaths could reach 5.
Do: 客观讲述存在的担忧,并提供数据依据,可信度更高。
people 并不是叙述的要点,担忧才是,所以用客观事实作主语
Expressions characterizing the news report
3. There is concern that the construction company that built the tower block had not followed the fire safety rules.
People are worried that the construction company that built the tower block had not followed the fire safety rules.
Do: 客观讲述存在的担心。
“people”无关紧要,不必提及
Expressions characterizing the news report
4. Emergency services estimate that the number of deaths could reach 9.
It is estimated that the number of deaths could reach 9.
Do: 可靠的信息源头要提及
Expressions characterizing the news report
5. By this morning, 4 people have been confirmed dead.
By this morning, it has been confirmed that 4 people are dead.
Do: 文字表达尽量简洁。
使用 confirm 表达可信度:证实
Expressions characterizing the news report
6. Lisa Mayer, 29, is among the lucky ones who only suffered minor injuries. She recalled, “ I was about to have a bath when I heard people screaming and dogs barking. ...”
7. Mr Peterson, head of the fire service, confirms that a dropped cigarette end on the carpet of the 8th floor started the fire and the ...did not go off quickly enough to prevent the disaster.
Do: 引用当事人的话,增加可信度 语言正式 confirm
The quotation is meant to provide a personal account of how serious the fire was , adding to the authenticity of the news report.
The traffic accident on Sunday morning killed five people. It was probably caused by a car driver speaking on his mobile phone. More and more people worry that speaking on the mobile phone when driving has been a big killer in recent years.
Present information in a factual and formal way
用一种基于事实且风格正式的方式呈现信息
Five people have been confirmed dead in the traffic accident on Sunday morning.
It was thought to have been caused by a car driver speaking on his mobile phone.
There is growing concern that speaking on the mobile phone when driving has been a big killer in recent years.
Five people have been confirmed dead in the traffic accident on Sunday morning, which was thought to have been caused by a car driver speaking on his mobile phone.
What information do you know about the incident
It is reported that a fire broke out in the Henderson Tower during the night of 9 July. Firefighters arrived within 15 minutes after being called and brought the fire under control within an hour and 15 minutes. By 11 July, 4 deaths had been confirmed, as well as dozens of injuries, including 5 in a critical condition.
Despite concerns that the construction company did not follow fire safety rules, the fire service confirmed that a dropped cigarette end on a carpet of the 8th floor had started the fire and the automatic fire alarms had failed to go off quickly enough. Further investigation into the event is currently ongoing.
News reports usually
Part 1: Para. .
Summarize the main idea of each paragraph by filling in the chart.
Reading news reports critically
Part 2: Paras. .
Part 3: Para. .
1
2-3
4
Differences between news reports may depend on
We can
in many ways.
come with differences
how and when the news reports are written.
become critical news
readers
Fast reading
Reading news reports critically Why do news reports differ from or even contradict each other (4) ______________________________________
News reports may be written at different stages of an event.
(5) ______________________________________.
How can we be critical news readers Read different news reports on the same event written from various perspectives and at different stages.
(6) ______________________________________
________________________________________.
It’s better to use our own judgement than rely entirely on news reports
Journalists may approach information they get from research or interviews differently
Journalists write the news from different perspectives
Detaied-reading
1. How long did it take the firefighters to get the situation under control according to the first news report
2. How did Lisa feel about the fire according to the second news report
A2
Read the two news reports and the article again carefully and answer the following questions.
About one hour and fifteen minutes.
She felt it was like an awful dream.
3. What should we not do when we come across factual differences in different news reports
4. What may different journalists do when an estimate of a number is given
When we come across such factual differences, we should not rush to the conclusion that one of the news reports gives false information.
Journalists may choose to present the minimum, the maximum or something in between in their news reports.
A2
Read the two news reports and the article again carefully and answer the following questions.
Be a critical news reader.
Don’t be a keyboard warrior.
Discussion
What else can we do to be critical news readers
Read more than headlines.
Cultivate your skepticism.
Find out who is making the claim.
Do more research on the news source.
Read coverge in multiple outlets.
Watch out for reports that rely on anonymous source.
Seperate fact from opinion.
...
Discussion
Be suspicious and chase the reality
Language points
1. Fears grew ________ the number of deaths could reach 5, according to figures _________(release) by emergency services.
2. There is concern ________ the construction company _____ built the tower block had not followed fire safety rules.
3. Another aspect worthy of mention is _______ journalists may approach information ______ they get from research or interviews differently.
4. We also need to be critical about the information we receive and remember not to blindly trust what we have read.
同位语从句
定语从句
that
released
that
that
that
that
Language points
5. The fire , ______ is thought to have started from the 8 floor, _________ (spread) quickly through the tower block on Sunday night, _________(leave) people on the upper floor trapped.
6. A terrible fire broke out on Sunday night, _______(leave) the Henderson Tower seriously ___________(damage).
7. The fire has also left dozens of people _________(injure), 5 of _________ are in a critical condition.
8. It is advisable to remember that journalists may have different priorities, ______ would influence how they report an event.
定语从句
which
spread
leaving
leaving
damaged
injured
whom
which
Language points
9. Fire engines and ambulances, ________(call) at 9:30 pm, reached the scene within 15 minutes.
10. By this time, the fire ______________(extend) to the 15th floor.
11. The company that built the tower block ______________(not follow) fire safety rules.
12. By this morning, 4 people ________________(confirm) dead.
过去完成时
called
had extended
had not followed
have been confirmed
Language points
13. I was about to have a bath _______ I heard people screaming and dogs barking.
14. When we come across such factual differences, we should not rush to the conclusion that one of the news reports gives false information. Instead, check when the reports were written.
News reports written at different stages of an event could contain different information _________ new facts are brought to light.
状语从句句式
when
as
Finish the exercise (P5)
How can we be a good journalist
priorities
dozens of
accurate
minor
comes about
Finish the exercise (P5)
are committed to
investigate
sum up
put out the fire
be thought to have done sth
leave sb trapped
emergency services
reach the scene
by this time
get sth under control
There is concern that
follow the safety rules
a fire broke out
be confirmed dead
in a critical condition
be about to do sth when
(ring/ alarm) go off
rely on sb to do sth
come about
it is advisable to do sth
have different priorities
take sth as an example
in terms of
for instance
rush to the conclusion that
be brought to light
be worthy of mention
draw a more informed conclusion
to sum up
from various perspectives
it's better to do sth
have the potential to do sth